Difference between revisions of "Suggestion"

From No Subject - Encyclopedia of Psychoanalysis
Jump to: navigation, search
(The LinkTitles extension automatically added links to existing pages (<a rel="nofollow" class="external free" href="https://github.com/bovender/LinkTitles">https://github.com/bovender/LinkTitles</a>).)
(Tags: Mobile edit, Mobile web edit)
 
(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
  
 
==Psychiatric Definition==
 
==Psychiatric Definition==
In nineteenth-century French psychiatry, the term "[[suggestion]]" referred to the use of hypnosis to remove [[neurotic]] [[symptoms]]; while the [[patient]] was in a state of hypnosis, the doctor would "[[suggest]]" that the [[symptom]]s would disappear.  
+
In nineteenth-century [[French]] [[psychiatry]], the term "[[suggestion]]" referred to the use of hypnosis to remove [[neurotic]] [[symptoms]]; while the [[patient]] was in a [[state]] of hypnosis, the doctor would "[[suggest]]" that the [[symptom]]s would [[disappear]].  
  
 
==Sigmund Freud==
 
==Sigmund Freud==
Line 10: Line 10:
 
However, he became increasingly dissatisfied with [[suggestion]], and thus came to abandon [[hypnosis]] and develop [[psychoanalysis]].  
 
However, he became increasingly dissatisfied with [[suggestion]], and thus came to abandon [[hypnosis]] and develop [[psychoanalysis]].  
  
The reasons for [[Freud]]'s dissatisfaction with [[hypnosis]] are hence fundamental for understanding the specific nature of [[psychoanalysis]].  
+
The reasons for [[Freud]]'s [[dissatisfaction]] with [[hypnosis]] are hence fundamental for [[understanding]] the specific [[nature]] of [[psychoanalysis]].  
  
However, it is beyond the scope of this article to enter into a detailed discussion of these reasons.  
+
However, it is beyond the scope of this article to enter into a detailed [[discussion]] of these reasons.  
  
 
==Psychoanalysis==
 
==Psychoanalysis==
Suffice it to say that in [[Freud]]'s later work the term "[[suggestion]]" comes to represent a whole set of ideas which [[Freud]] associates with hypnosis and which is thus diametrically opposed to [[psychoanalysis]].
+
Suffice it to say that in [[Freud]]'s later [[work]] the term "[[suggestion]]" comes to [[represent]] a [[whole]] set of [[ideas]] which [[Freud]] associates with hypnosis and which is thus diametrically opposed to [[psychoanalysis]].
  
 
==Jacques Lacan==
 
==Jacques Lacan==
Following [[Freud]], [[Lacan]] uses the term "[[suggestion]]" to designate a whole range of deviations from true [[psychoanalysis]] (deviations which [[Lacan]] also refers to as "[[psychotherapy]]"), of which the following are perhaps the most salient:
+
Following [[Freud]], [[Lacan]] uses the term "[[suggestion]]" to designate a whole range of deviations from [[true]] [[psychoanalysis]] (deviations which [[Lacan]] also refers to as "[[psychotherapy]]"), of which the following are perhaps the most salient:
  
 
===Direction Toward Moral Value===
 
===Direction Toward Moral Value===
:1. [[Suggestion]] includes the idea of directing the [[patient]] towards some [[ideal]] or some [[moral]] value.  
+
:1. [[Suggestion]] includes the [[idea]] of directing the [[patient]] towards some [[ideal]] or some [[moral]] [[value]].  
 
: In opposition to this, [[Lacan]] reminds [[analysts]] that their task is to direct the [[treatment]], not the [[patient]].<ref>{{E}} p.227</ref>
 
: In opposition to this, [[Lacan]] reminds [[analysts]] that their task is to direct the [[treatment]], not the [[patient]].<ref>{{E}} p.227</ref>
:[[Lacan]] is opposed to any conception of [[psychoanalysis]] as a normative process of social influence.
+
:[[Lacan]] is opposed to any conception of [[psychoanalysis]] as a [[normative]] [[process]] of [[social]] influence.
  
 
===Resistance to Treatment===
 
===Resistance to Treatment===
Line 36: Line 36:
 
[[Suggestion]] has a close relation with [[transference]].<ref>{{E}} p. 270</ref>
 
[[Suggestion]] has a close relation with [[transference]].<ref>{{E}} p. 270</ref>
  
If [[transference]] involves the [[analysand]] attributing [[knowledge]] to the [[analyst]], [[suggestion]] refers to a particular way of responding to this attribution.  
+
If [[transference]] involves the [[analysand]] attributing [[knowledge]] to the [[analyst]], [[suggestion]] refers to a [[particular]] way of responding to this [[attribution]].  
  
 
==Position of the Analyst==
 
==Position of the Analyst==
[[Lacan]] argues that the [[analyst]] must realize that he only occupies the position of one who is presumed (by the [[analysand]]) to know, without fooling himself that he really does possess the [[knowledge]] attributed to him.  
+
[[Lacan]] argues that the [[analyst]] must realize that he only occupies the [[position]] of one who is presumed (by the [[analysand]]) to [[know]], without fooling himself that he really does possess the [[knowledge]] attributed to him.  
  
In this way, the [[analyst]] is able to transform the [[transference]] into "an analysis of suggestion."<ref>{{E}} p.271</ref>
+
In this way, the [[analyst]] is able to transform the [[transference]] into "an [[analysis]] of suggestion."<ref>{{E}} p.271</ref>
  
[[Suggestion]], on the other hand, arises when the [[analyst]] assumes the position of one who really does know.
+
[[Suggestion]], on the [[other]] hand, arises when the [[analyst]] assumes the position of one who really does know.
  
 
==Hypnosis and Psychoanalysis==
 
==Hypnosis and Psychoanalysis==
Like [[Freud]], [[Lacan]] sees [[hypnosis]] as the model of [[suggestion]].  
+
Like [[Freud]], [[Lacan]] sees [[hypnosis]] as the [[model]] of [[suggestion]].  
  
 
In ''[[Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego]]'', [[Freud]] shows how hypnotism makes the [[object]] converge with the [[ego-ideal]].<ref>{{F}} ''[[Works of Sigmund Freud|Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego]]'', 1921. [[SE]] XVIII, 69.</ref>  
 
In ''[[Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego]]'', [[Freud]] shows how hypnotism makes the [[object]] converge with the [[ego-ideal]].<ref>{{F}} ''[[Works of Sigmund Freud|Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego]]'', 1921. [[SE]] XVIII, 69.</ref>  
  
To put this in [[Lacan]]ian terms, [[hypnotism]] involves the convergence of the [[object]] ''a'' and the I.  
+
To put this in [[Lacan]]ian [[terms]], [[hypnotism]] involves the convergence of the [[object]] ''a'' and the I.  
  
[[Psychoanalysis]] involves exactly the opposite, since "the fundamental mainspring of the analytic operation is the maintenance of the distance between I - identification - and the ''a''."<ref>{{S11}} p. 273</ref>.
+
[[Psychoanalysis]] involves exactly the opposite, since "the fundamental mainspring of the [[analytic]] operation is the maintenance of the distance between I - [[identification]] - and the ''a''."<ref>{{S11}} p. 273</ref>.
  
 
==See also==
 
==See also==
Line 73: Line 73:
  
 
==References==
 
==References==
 +
<div style="font-size:11px" class="references-small">
 
<references/>
 
<references/>
 +
</div>
  
 
[[Category:Imaginary]]
 
[[Category:Imaginary]]

Latest revision as of 00:05, 21 May 2019

French: suggestion

Psychiatric Definition

In nineteenth-century French psychiatry, the term "suggestion" referred to the use of hypnosis to remove neurotic symptoms; while the patient was in a state of hypnosis, the doctor would "suggest" that the symptoms would disappear.

Sigmund Freud

Taking his cue from the French psychiatrists Charcot and Bernheim, Freud began using suggestion to treat neurotic patients in the 1880s.

Treatment

However, he became increasingly dissatisfied with suggestion, and thus came to abandon hypnosis and develop psychoanalysis.

The reasons for Freud's dissatisfaction with hypnosis are hence fundamental for understanding the specific nature of psychoanalysis.

However, it is beyond the scope of this article to enter into a detailed discussion of these reasons.

Psychoanalysis

Suffice it to say that in Freud's later work the term "suggestion" comes to represent a whole set of ideas which Freud associates with hypnosis and which is thus diametrically opposed to psychoanalysis.

Jacques Lacan

Following Freud, Lacan uses the term "suggestion" to designate a whole range of deviations from true psychoanalysis (deviations which Lacan also refers to as "psychotherapy"), of which the following are perhaps the most salient:

Direction Toward Moral Value

1. Suggestion includes the idea of directing the patient towards some ideal or some moral value.
In opposition to this, Lacan reminds analysts that their task is to direct the treatment, not the patient.[1]
Lacan is opposed to any conception of psychoanalysis as a normative process of social influence.

Resistance to Treatment

2. Suggestion also arises when the patient's resistance is seen as something that must be liquidated by the analyst.
Such a view is completely foreign to psychoanalysis, argues Lacan, since the analyst recognizes that a certain residue of resistance is inherent in the structure of the treatment.

Interpretation, Signification and Meaning

3. In suggestion, the interpretations of the therapist are orientated around signification, whereas the analyst orientates his interpretations around meaning (sens) and its correlate, nonsense.
Thus whereas in psychotherapy there is an attempt to avoid the ambiguity and equivocation of discourse, it is precisely this ambiguity which psychoanalysis thrives on.

Transference

Suggestion has a close relation with transference.[2]

If transference involves the analysand attributing knowledge to the analyst, suggestion refers to a particular way of responding to this attribution.

Position of the Analyst

Lacan argues that the analyst must realize that he only occupies the position of one who is presumed (by the analysand) to know, without fooling himself that he really does possess the knowledge attributed to him.

In this way, the analyst is able to transform the transference into "an analysis of suggestion."[3]

Suggestion, on the other hand, arises when the analyst assumes the position of one who really does know.

Hypnosis and Psychoanalysis

Like Freud, Lacan sees hypnosis as the model of suggestion.

In Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego, Freud shows how hypnotism makes the object converge with the ego-ideal.[4]

To put this in Lacanian terms, hypnotism involves the convergence of the object a and the I.

Psychoanalysis involves exactly the opposite, since "the fundamental mainspring of the analytic operation is the maintenance of the distance between I - identification - and the a."[5].

See also

References

  1. Lacan, Jacques. Écrits: A Selection. Trans. Alan Sheridan. London: Tavistock Publications, 1977. p.227
  2. Lacan, Jacques. Écrits: A Selection. Trans. Alan Sheridan. London: Tavistock Publications, 1977. p. 270
  3. Lacan, Jacques. Écrits: A Selection. Trans. Alan Sheridan. London: Tavistock Publications, 1977. p.271
  4. Freud, Sigmund. Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego, 1921. SE XVIII, 69.
  5. Lacan, Jacques. The Seminar. Book XI. The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis, 1964. Trans. Alan Sheridan. London: Hogarth Press and Institute of Psycho-Analysis, 1977. p. 273