Changes

Jump to: navigation, search

Truth

4,245 bytes removed, 02:53, 21 May 2019
The LinkTitles extension automatically added links to existing pages (<a rel="nofollow" class="external free" href="https://github.com/bovender/LinkTitles">https://github.com/bovender/LinkTitles</a>).
{{Top}}vérité{{Bottom}}
[[Truth]] is one of the most central, and yet most [[complex]] [[terms]] in [[Lacan]]'s [[discourse]].
[[Truth]] is one of the most central, and yet most complex terms in [[Lacan]]'s discourse.  ==Truth and Psychoanalytic TreatmentPsychoanalysis==
The [[aim]] of [[psychoanalytic]] [[treatment]] is to lead the [[analysand]] to articulate the [[truth]] of his or her [[desire]].
[[Truth]] does not await, in some preformed [[state ]] of fullness, to be revealed to the [[analysand]] by the [[analyst]], but is rather constructed in the [[dialectic]]al movement of the [[treatment]] itself.<ref>{{Ec}} p.144</ref>
==Truth and Philosophy==
[[Lacan]] argues, in opposition to the traditions of classical [[philosophy]], that [[truth]] is not beautiful<ref>{{S7}} p.217</ref> and that it is not necessarily beneficial to learn the [[truth]].<ref>{{S17}} p.122</ref>
[[Lacan]] speaks [[about ]] "[[truth]]" in the [[singular]], not as a single [[universal]] [[truth]], but as [[particular]] [[truth]], unique to each [[subject]].<ref>{{S7}} p.24</ref>  ==Language==[[Truth]] is only a meaningful [[concept]] in the context of [[language]]:
==Truth and Language==[[Truth]] is only a meaningful concept in the context of [[language]]: <blockquote>"It is with the appearance of [[language]] that the [[dimension ]] of [[truth]] emerges."<ref>{{E}} p.172</ref></blockquote>
[[Psychoanalytic]] [[treatment]] is based on the fundamental premise that [[speech]] is the only means of revealing the [[truth]] about [[desire]].
<blockquote>"[[Truth]] hollows its way into the [[real]] thanks to the dimension of [[speech]]. There is neither [[true]] nor [[false]] prior to [[speech]]."<ref>{{S1}} p.228</ref></blockquote>
==Truth and [[Science]]==
From [[Lacan]]'s earliest writings, the term "[[truth]]" has metaphysical, even mystical, nuances which problematise any attempt to articulate [[truth]] and [[science]].
It is not that [[Lacan]] denies that [[science]] aims to [[know ]] the [[truth]], but simply that [[science]] cannot [[claim ]] to monopolise [[truth]] as its exclusive property.<ref>{{Ec}} p.79</ref>
[[Lacan]] later argues that [[science]] is in fact based on a [[foreclosure]] of the concept of [[truth]] as [[cause]].<ref>{{Ec}} p.874</ref>
The concept of [[truth]] is essential for [[understanding ]] [[madness]], and modern [[science]] renders [[madness]] meaningless by ignoring the concept of [[truth]].<ref>{{Ec}} p.153-4</ref>
==Truth and Deception==
[[Truth]] is intimately connected with [[deception]], since lies can often reveal the [[truth]] about [[desire]] more eloquently than honest statements.
[[TruthDeception]] is intimately connected with and lies are not the opposite of [[deceptiontruth]]: on the contrary, since lies can often reveal they are inscribed in the [[truthtext]] about of [[desiretruth]] more eloquently than honest statements.
The [[Deceptionanalyst]] and lies are not 's [[role]] is to reveal the opposite of [[truth]]: on the contrary, they are inscribed in the text [[deception]] of the [[analysand]]'s [[truthspeech]].
The Although the [[analystanalysand]]'s role is may in effect be saying to reveal the [[truthanalyst]] inscribed in "I am deceiving you," the [[deceptionanalyst]] of says to the [[analysand]]'s [[speech]]. :
Although the [[analysand]] may in effect be saying to the [[analyst]] "I am deceiving you," the [[analyst]] says to the [[analysand]] <blockquote>"In this I am deceiving to you, what you are sending as [[message ]] is what I express to you, and in doing so you are telling the truth.<ref>{{S11}} p.139-40; {{S4}} p.107-8)</ref></blockquote>
==Truth versus false appearancesFalse Appearances==The false [[appearance]]s presented by the [[analysand]] are not merely obstacles that the [[analyst]] must expose and discard in [[order ]] to discover the [[truth]]; on the contrary, the [[analyst]] must take [[them ]] into account (see [[semblance]]).
==Truth, error Error and mistakesMistakes==[[Psychoanalysis]] has shown that the [[truth]] about [[desire]] is often revealed by mistakes ([[parapraxes]]).
The complex relations between [[truth]], mistakes, error and [[deception]] are evoked by [[Lacan]] in a typically elusive phrase when he describes "the [[structuration ]] of speech in [[search ]] of truth" as "error taking flight in deception and recaptured by mistake."<ref>{{S1}} p. 273</ref>
==Truth and Fiction==[[Lacan]] does not use the term "[[fiction]]" in the [[sense ]] of 'a falsehood', but in the sense of a [[scientific]] [[construct]].<ref>{{S7}} p.12</ref>
Thus [[Lacan]]'s term "[[fiction]]" corresponds to [[Freud]]'s term ''Konvention'', convention,<ref>{{S11}} p.163</ref> and has more in common with [[truth]] than falsehood.
Indeed, [[Lacan]] states that [[truth]] is [[structure]]d like a [[fiction]].<ref>{{E}} 306; {{Ec}} 808</ref>
==Truth and the realThe Real==The opposition which [[Lacan]] draws between [[truth]] and the [[real]] dates back to his pre-war writings,<ref>{{Ec}} p.75</ref> and is taken up at various points; "We are used to the real. The truth we repress."<ref>{{E}} p.169</ref>
However, [[Lacan]] also points out that [[truth]] is similar <blockquote>"We are used to the [[real]]; it is impossible to articulate the whole [[. The truth]], and "[p]recisely because of this [[impossibility]], we [[truthrepress]] aspires to the real."<ref>Lacan, 1973a: 83{{E}} p.169</ref></blockquote>
==definition==Sigmund Freud's notion of truth evolved from a factual conception into a relativistic method where the true and the false are defined both in relation to a conventional and bounded space (that of the cure) and the dynamic effects that "plausible" constructions might have on the psyche.  Truth as an objective no longer remains "the fundamental rule of psychoanalysis."<ref>1914gHowever, pp. 147, 150</ref> It inclines towards the notion of reality testing that demands that the subject partially abandon their illusions.  Truth as an ideal is inseparable from psychoanalytic inquiry and is unattainable, except partially in the "nuclei" of truth present within individual and collective distortions. The search for factors that cause psychic suffering can be confused with the search for truth inasmuch as they are both repressed, misrepresented, displaced, represented by their opposite, and the like.  Initially Freud imagined rediscovering the traumatic events in the histories of his patients themselves, but promptly noticing "[[Lacan]] also points out that there are no indications of reality in the unconscious, so that one cannot distinguish between the [[truth and fiction that ]] is cathected with affect" (letter similar to Wilhelm Fleiss, 21 September 1897), he ended up privileging the psychical reality of the subject, wherein a dynamic verisimilitude was elaborated which would take on the value of truth.  This relativization of truth seems to coincide with a Pirandellian conception of it (Each in His Own Way).  In fact, truth as a value has not disappeared from the Freudian purview but [[real]]; it has become subtler.  Thus interpretation is not about the exhumation of truth but rather construction through the adoption of a coherent paradigm (Viderman, 1970), originating from [[impossible]] to articulate the unperceived formulations of the subject's free associations or dreams. Thus for Jacques Lacan, [[whole]] [[truth extricates itself from reality:  "In psychoanalytic anamnesis]], it is not a question of reality, but of truth, because the effect of full speech is to reorder past contingencies by conferring on them the sense of necessities to come."<ref>1956, p. 48</ref> Truth is not precisely being true to reality, rather it speaks and stutters through its symptomatic distortions. The analyst has to engage with these "nuclei" of truth, then; Freud, for instance, defined them in relation to the sexual theories of children, which despite being untrue nonetheless each contain "a fragment of real truth."<ref>1908c, [p. 215</ref> This is an adult, intellectual mode of investigation whose results, ]recisely because they are limited to the possibilities of human understandingthis [[impossibility]], would have been false in relation to a broader perspective, but which include nevertheless "inspired" partial but significant interpretations. The quest for truth proceeds from a "[[truth fantasy" (Mijolla-Mellor, 1985), which relates ]] aspires to an image of lost harmony (transparency, luminosity) within the I, the others, and one's self.  Truth, in terms of the demand for truthfulness, is central to the fundamental rule that requires the abandonment of secrecy; however, it also guides the behavior of the analyst in their relationship with the patient, in their vision of the world, and in their research, requiring them to relinquish personal illusions for the construction of a coherent schema.  Challenging illusion and narcissistic comfort, truth, according to Freud, is a force in its own right:  "The hardest truths are heard and recognized at last, after the interests they have injured and the emotions they have roused have exhausted their furyreal."<ref>1910d, {{TV}} p. 21583</ref> Piera Aulagnier gives truth a central place in relation to the identity of the subject.  It is the object of a "battle never definitively won nor lost to which periodically the I must surrender in order to modify and defend its positions, failing which it would be unable to turn towards or invest in its own identificatory space."<ref>1984, p. 147</ref> The notion of truth in psychoanalysis is tied to the history the subject, in the same way as it is to humanity, because it is not simply a case of a balance between understanding and the thing, but of a narrative that is reconstructed using the residues left behind by legend.
==See Also==
{{See}}
* [[Analysand]]
* [[Analyst]]
* [[Cause]]
* [[Desire]]
||
* [[Dialectic]]
* [[Philosophy]]
* [[Science]]
* [[Semblance]]
||
* [[Speech]]
* [[Structure]]
* [[Subject]]
* [[Treatment]]
{{Also}}
==References==
<div style="font-size:11px" class="references-small">
<references/>
# Freud, Sigmund. (1908c). On the sexual theories of children. SE, 9: 205-226.# ——. 1910d). The future prospects of psycho-analytic therapy. SE, 11: 139-151.# ——. (1950a [1887-1902]). Extracts from the Fliess papers. SE, 1: 173-280.</div># Lacan, Jacques. (1989). Ecrits: A Selection. (Alan Sheridan, Trans.) 5th ed. London: Tavistock/Routledge.63-5, 141-3 Conversations__NOTOC__
[[Category:Psychoanalysis]]
[[Category:Terms]]
[[Category:Edit]]
{{OK}}
Anonymous user

Navigation menu