Seminar II

From No Subject - Encyclopedia of Psychoanalysis
Jump to: navigation, search
Seminar I Seminar III

1954 - 1955 Seminar II Le moi dans la théorie de Freud et dans la technique de la psychanalyse
The Ego in Freud's Theory and in the Technique of Psychoanalysis

Lacan deliberates on the distinction made in his first seminar between discourse analysis and the analysis of the ego, both in relation to psychoanalytical theory and practice. He claims that "analysis deals with resistances." He reviews three works by Freud: Beyond the Pleasure Principle, on the death drive; Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego; and The Ego and the Id.

Consciousness is transparent to itself, whereas the I (je) or 'ego' is not. The I is outside the field of consciousness and its certainties (where we represent ourselves as ego, where something exists and is expressed by the I). But it is not enough to say that 'the I of the unconscious is not the ego' since we tend to think this I as the true ego. Lacan proceeds to re-assert the locus of the ego and reinstate the excentricity of the subject vis-à-vis the ego.

The ego is a particular object within the experience of the subject, with a certain function: an imaginary one. When in the specular image the ego is recognized as such by the subject, this image becomes self-conscious. "The mirror stage is based on the rapport [relationship] between, on one hand, a certain level of tendencies which are experienced as disconnected and, on the other, a unity with which it is merged and paired. In this unity the subject knows itself as unity, but as an alienated, virtual one."

However, for a consciousness to perceive another consciousness, the symbolic order must intervene on the system determined by the image of the ego, as a dimension of re-connaissance.

In "The Dream of Irma's Injection" the most tragic moment occurs in the confrontation with the Real - the ultimate Real, "something in front of which words stop." "In the dream the unconscious is what is outside all of the subjects. The structure of the dream shows that the unconscious is not the ego of the dreamer." "This subject outside the subject designates the whole structure of the dream." "What is at stake in the function of the dream is beyond the ego, what in the subject is of the subject and not of the subject, that is the unconscious."

In his analysis of Poe's Purloined Letter, Lacan speaks of "an other beyond all subjectivity." The question concerns the "confrontation of the subject beyond the ego with the Id, the quod (what-is-it?) which seeks to come into being in analysis."

"The purloined letter is synonymous with the original, radical subject of the unconscious. The symbol is being displaced in its pure state: one cannot come into contact with without being caught in its play. There is nothing in destiny, or casualty, which can be defined as a function of existence. When the characters get hold of this letter, something gets hold of them and carries them along. At each stage of the symbolic transformation of the letter, they will be defined by their position in relation to this radical object. This position is not fixed. As they enter into the necessity peculiar to the letter, they each become functionally different to the essential reality of the letter. For each of them the letter is the unconscious, with all its consequences, namely that at each point of the symbolic circuit, each of them becomes someone else."

When Jean Hyppolite asks: "What use does the Symbolic have?" Lacan answers: "The Symbolic, the Imaginary and the Real are useful in giving its meaning to a particularly pure symbolic experience, that of analysis." Since the symbolic dimension is the only dimension that cures, "The symbolic order is simultaneously non-being and insisting to be, that is what Freud has in mind when he talks about the death instinct as being what is most fundamental: a symbolic order in travail, in the process of coming, insisting in being realized."


The Schema L, systematized in the Seminar on 'The Purloined Letter' (La lettre volée) (Écrits, 1966), is elaborated in this seminar. A four-term structure maps the Real, the Imaginary and the Symbolic as replacing the second Freudian topography: ego / id / superego. Two diagonals intersect, while the imaginary rapport links a (the ego) to a' (the other), the line going from S (the subject, the Freudian id) to A (the Other) is interrupted by the first one. The Other is difficult to define: it is the place of language where subjectivity is constituted; it is the place of primal speech linked to the Father; it is the place of the absolute Other, the mother in the demand. The Other makes the subject without him knowing it. With Lacan, in Freud's Wo Es war, soll Ich werden, Es is the subject. It knows him or doesn't. The further, more exacting insight, is It speaks or doesn't. At the end of analysis, it is It who must be called on to speak, and to enter in relation with real Others. Where S was, there the Ich should be.

English Translation

Author(s) Title Publisher Year Pages Language Size Extension Mirrors
Jacques Lacan, Jacques-Alain Miller, Sylvana Tomaselli The Seminar of Jacques Lacan
The Ego in Freud's Theory and in the Technique of Psychoanalysis, 1954-1955 Book II
0393307093, 9780393307092
W.W. Norton & Co. 1991 300


English 6 Mb pdf 1, 2, 3, 4, 5

Related Documents

Author(s) Title Publisher Year Pages Language Size Extension Mirrors
Richard Feldstein, Bruce Fink, Maire Jaanus SUNY Series in Psychoanalysis & Culture
Reading Seminars I and II: Lacan’s Return to Freud
0791427803, 9780791427804
State University of New York Press 1996 460
English 3 Mb pdf 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Richard Feldstein, Bruce Fink, Maire Jaanus SUNY Series in Psychoanalysis & Culture
Reading Seminars I and II: Lacan’s Return to Freud
0791427803, 9780791427804
State University of New York Press 1996 445 English 7 Mb pdf 1, 2, 3, 4, 5


Date PDF
17 novembre 1954 link
1 décembre 1954 link
8 décembre 1954 link
15 décembre 1954 link
12 janvier 1955 link
19 janvier 1955 link
26 janvier 1955 link
2 février 1955 link
9 février 1955 link
16 février 1955 link
2 mars 1955 link
9 mars 1955 link
16 mars 1955 link
30 mars 1955 link
12 mai 1955 link
19 mai 1955 link
25 mai 1955 link
1 juin 1955 link
8 juin 1955 link
15 juin 1955 link
22 juin 1955 link
29 juin 1955 link

French versions of Lacan's Seminars Source:

You do not have permission to embed PDF files.