Working through
Working through (German: Durcharbeiten) is a foundational technical and metapsychological concept in psychoanalysis, introduced by Sigmund Freud to describe the gradual, repetitive process by which unconscious conflicts are psychically transformed through analytic work. Unlike interpretation, insight, or emotional discharge alone, working through designates a temporal, experiential, and affective labor by which unconscious formations—symptoms, fantasies, defenses, and repetitive relational patterns—are progressively modified through their repeated emergence and elaboration in the analytic setting.
Freud developed the concept in response to a central clinical problem: the observation that making the unconscious conscious does not in itself bring about lasting change. Instead, psychic transformation requires a sustained process in which unconscious material is repeatedly encountered, tolerated, symbolized, and reworked—particularly as it manifests in resistance, repetition, and transference. Working through thus names both a clinical task and a structural process of psychic change, central to psychoanalytic theory and practice.
Although the term Durcharbeiten is specific to Freud, later psychoanalytic traditions—most notably Lacanian psychoanalysis—have reinterpreted its function within different conceptual frameworks, shifting emphasis from ego mastery and conflict resolution toward the restructuring of the subject’s relation to desire, jouissance, and the symbolic order.
Definition and Overview
In Freud’s technical writings, working through refers to the process by which the analysand gradually comes to recognize, endure, and transform unconscious material that resists immediate integration. Freud defines it as the patient’s labor of repeatedly confronting unconscious conflicts—especially as they appear in resistance and transference—until these conflicts lose their rigidity and compulsive force.[1]
Working through must be distinguished from:
- Interpretation, which introduces unconscious meaning into speech;
- Insight, which may remain intellectual or fleeting;
- Catharsis, which relies on emotional discharge without structural change.
Rather than promising rapid resolution, working through emphasizes duration, repetition, and affective experience. It operates precisely where resistance persists despite correct interpretation and is inseparable from the analytic situation itself, particularly the lived dynamics of transference.
Freud regarded working through as indispensable for durable analytic change, since unconscious conflicts are not eliminated but must be re-lived, re-symbolized, and re-integrated within the analytic relationship.
Historical Origins and Freudian Formulation
Remembering, Repeating and Working‑Through (1914)
The concept of working through emerges explicitly in Freud’s 1914 paper “Remembering, Repeating and Working‑Through”, written during a decisive period of refinement in psychoanalytic technique. Freud observed that patients frequently fail to remember repressed material directly; instead, they repeat it in action, particularly within the transference relationship.[1]
This repetition manifests as:
- Persistent resistances to interpretation;
- Recurrent affective reactions toward the analyst;
- Symptomatic behaviors enacted rather than remembered.
Freud concluded that interpretation alone is insufficient to overcome such resistance. The analyst must allow the patient to repeat the unconscious conflict under analytic conditions, where it can be gradually worked through rather than acted out destructively. The analyst’s task is therefore not to eliminate repetition prematurely, but to render it analyzable.
Earlier Technical Context
Although Durcharbeiten appears explicitly only in 1914, its logic is already implicit in Freud’s earlier works. In The Interpretation of Dreams (1900), Freud emphasized that dream analysis proceeds through iterative associative elaboration, not immediate decoding or symbolic translation.[2]
Likewise, in “The Dynamics of Transference” (1912), Freud stressed that transference resistance must be experienced and interpreted repeatedly before it loses its force, anticipating the later concept of working through.[3]
Working through thus emerges as Freud’s solution to the problem of therapeutic durability: how analytic change can become structural rather than superficial.
Mechanism and Clinical Dynamics
Resistance as Process, Not Obstacle
At the heart of working through lies resistance—the unconscious opposition to making repressed material conscious and affectively meaningful. Freud emphasized that resistance does not vanish once interpreted; instead, it reappears in new forms, requiring sustained analytic engagement.
Working through involves:
- Repeated confrontation with resistance;
- Gradual loosening of defensive structures;
- Increased tolerance for psychic conflict and ambivalence.
Freud stressed that this process is inherently slow and often frustrating, demanding patience and restraint from both analyst and analysand.[1]
Repetition, Transference, and Countertransference
The transference is the privileged site of working through. Unconscious conflicts are not merely recalled as historical facts but are relived in the analytic relationship, where they can be interpreted, contained, and transformed.
Although Freud did not fully theorize countertransference, later analytic traditions have emphasized its role as an indicator of unconscious dynamics being enacted rather than verbalized, thereby contributing to the working‑through process.
Symbolization and Re-symbolization
Working through enables unconscious material to shift from enactment to representation. Through repeated interpretation, free association, and affective experience, the subject gradually develops new symbolic relations to desires and conflicts that were previously fixed in repetitive action.
Transference and Repetition Compulsion
Repetition Compulsion
Freud’s introduction of repetition compulsion (Wiederholungszwang) in Beyond the Pleasure Principle (1920) deepened the theoretical significance of working through. Freud observed that patients compulsively repeat painful or traumatic experiences that do not conform to the pleasure principle.[4]
Working through becomes the analytic means by which repetition compulsion can be metabolized symbolically, rather than endlessly reenacted.
Emotional Resistance
Even when unconscious content is intellectually understood, affective resistance frequently persists. Working through addresses this gap by allowing the patient to experience unconscious conflict emotionally, within tolerable limits, thereby weakening its compulsive grip.
Lacanian Considerations
Repetition, the Signifier, and the Real
Although Jacques Lacan rarely employed the term working through, the concept is implicitly reconfigured within his theoretical framework. For Lacan, repetition is not a behavioral habit to be overcome but a function of the signifier and the subject’s relation to the Real—that which resists symbolization.
In Seminar XI, Lacan situates repetition alongside the unconscious, transference, and drive as one of the four fundamental concepts of psychoanalysis, emphasizing that repetition marks the point where signification fails and jouissance insists.[5]
From this perspective, working through is less a gradual elimination of resistance than a repositioning of the subject in relation to the symbolic order and desire.
Traversal of the Fantasy
Lacanian theory reframes the endpoint of working through as the traversal of the fundamental fantasy, whereby the subject ceases to be unconsciously governed by the fantasy that structures desire. This traversal does not abolish repetition but alters the subject’s relation to it, allowing desire to be assumed rather than compulsively enacted.
Working through thus becomes a process of symbolic repetition with difference, rather than linear clarification or ego mastery.
Relation to Interpretation, Insight, and Resistance
Freud consistently warned against equating interpretation with cure. Interpretation introduces meaning, but working through gives that meaning psychic efficacy.
Working through differs from interpretation in that it:
- Requires time and repetition;
- Involves affect as well as cognition;
- Operates within the transference rather than outside it.
Through working through, interpretations gradually lose their novelty and defensive resistance diminishes, allowing unconscious structures to loosen rather than collapse abruptly.
Clinical Examples and Applications
Freud described patients who repeatedly reenact dependency, hostility, or abandonment in the transference. Over time, through repeated interpretation and lived experience, these patterns lose their inevitability.
For example, a recurring dream motif may initially appear static, but across sessions it acquires new associations and meanings as defensive rigidity softens. The dream may persist, but the subject’s relation to it changes, marking the effect of working through rather than resolution.
Post‑Freudian Developments and Debates
Ego Psychology and Object Relations
Ego psychology emphasized working through as a process of ego strengthening and integration. Object relations theorists reconceptualized it as the gradual transformation of internal object relationships, shifting focus from drives to relational patterns.
Relational and Trauma‑Focused Perspectives
Relational psychoanalysis highlights the co‑constructed nature of working through, while trauma‑focused approaches question whether repetition always leads to symbolization, especially in cases of severe trauma.
Despite these debates, working through remains widely regarded as indispensable for understanding how analytic change unfolds over time.
Interdisciplinary and Philosophical Reflections
Beyond psychoanalysis, the concept of working through has influenced philosophy and cultural theory. Theodor W. Adorno’s reflections on Vergangenheitsbewältigung (“working through the past”) draw explicitly on Freud to describe the ethical labor of confronting historical trauma rather than repressing it.[6]
In literary and cultural studies, working through has been used to analyze narrative repetition, trauma, and collective memory.
Summary
Working through (Durcharbeiten) is a foundational psychoanalytic concept describing the slow, repetitive, and affectively charged process by which unconscious conflicts are transformed. Introduced by Freud to address resistance and repetition, and reinterpreted by Lacan in structural terms, it articulates a central truth of psychoanalysis: psychic change is not instantaneous but occurs through time, repetition, and symbolic labor.
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Sigmund Freud, “Remembering, Repeating and Working‑Through” (1914), in The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. XII, Hogarth Press, 1958, pp. 147–156.
- ↑ Sigmund Freud, The Interpretation of Dreams, SE Vols. IV–V, Hogarth Press, 1953, esp. pp. 529–532.
- ↑ Sigmund Freud, “The Dynamics of Transference” (1912), SE Vol. XII, Hogarth Press, 1958, pp. 97–108.
- ↑ Sigmund Freud, Beyond the Pleasure Principle, SE Vol. XVIII, Hogarth Press, 1955, pp. 18–23.
- ↑ Jacques Lacan, The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XI: The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis, trans. Alan Sheridan, W.W. Norton, 1977, pp. 61–64.
- ↑ Theodor W. Adorno, “The Meaning of Working Through the Past,” in Critical Models, Columbia University Press, 1998.
TimeTraumaNavbox}}